An emotionally charged Chino Valley school board meeting on Thursday ended with the majority voting to approve new sexual education curriculum materials for grades 7 through 12.  

School board members Irene Hernandez, Christina Gagnier and Joe Schaffer voted for the curriculum which will be used starting this school year. Board president James Na and member Andrew Cruz voted no.

The materials had been recommended by a committee that included five community members selected by each of the five school board members.    

Mr. Na and Mr. Cruz were largely supported by the attending audience in their opposition to adopting the material, which complies with the California Healthy Youth Act (AB 329) approved by the legislature in 2015.   

The Act’s tenets include education on human development and sexuality, including education on pregnancy, contraception and sexually transmitted diseases. 

The audience gave thunderous applause after each of the five public speakers who addressed the board spoke critically about legislation which they say promotes abortions and LGBTQ lifestyle. 

Mrs. Hernandez was heckled by audience members when she said her role was to represent all students.   

Some called out insults including “liar” when Mrs. Hernandez stated the district’s materials were not pornographic, causing Mr. Schaffer to shout to board president Na to call the meeting to order.

Mr. Schaffer also asked security to remove an audience member.  

“There is very little to like about the California Healthy Youth Act,” said Gina Gleason, director of public policy at Calvary Chapel Chino Hills, during public comments.  

She asked that the district make sure parents understand that they can opt out of the sex education course.  

Superintendent Norm Enfield said opt-out forms for parents are posted on the district website,  

Chino Hills parent Jennifer Zhao said she had reviewed the district’s new curriculum during the public review period and found it more conservative than what she believes other school districts are using.

She believes however that the law undermines the values of many Chinese parents who live within the district. 

“There is a danger that I see in normalizing different sexual orientations that is harmful to children,” she said. 

She said she was worried that teachers would provide students with resources listed in the high school curriculum material. 

“Children give their trust to their teachers,” she said. 

Mrs. Zhao voiced agreement with parent Michael Chu, also in attendance, when he said his concerns are that abortion, gender fluidity and divorce become normalized. 

Mrs. Zhao and Mr. Chu are among about 485 parents from Chino Hills High, Ayala High and Canyon Hills Junior High who are signed up to receive information in Chinese from Informed Parents of California.

According to its website, the group is a statewide resource to informparents on critical issues that impact children’s educational well-being and the role of parents in education.

There are 34,673 members on its Facebook page.   

Mr. Cruz and Mr. Na each took two turns speaking on the sex education curriculum before the vote.  

Mr. Cruz told the packed school board and overflow audience watching from large screens outside the board room, “It’s good you don’t trust the system. The direction it’s going is straight to pedophilia.”   

Mr. Na said the Act promotes abortion which leads to fewer children attending public schools.  

Referring to an earlier presentation given by district staff on declining enrollment in the Chino Valley school district, Mr. Na said laws like this will drive parents away from the district and towards private schools and homeschool program. 

Mrs. Gleason said Calvary Chapel Chino Hills is hosting speakers from around the state on the California Healthy Youth Act from 9 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. on Saturday, Aug. 24. 

The church is located at  4201 Eucalyptus Ave., Chino.

Recommended for you

(4) comments


Pretty scary that parents are treating children in this manner...all children should be respected, no matter their identity.


The audience yelled insults? Why were they allowed to stay in the meeting?


SexEd becoming a law means that the majority of Californian made the wrong decision. Some people can never understand why there is a small portion of Californian can have a peaceful life and happy family, while don't need to buy lottery tickets, drink alcohol, gamble, smoke marijuana, divorce, and have abortions. We have the freedom to do wrong things, but we simply don't need to do it. Only the most stupid students will don't get drunk while taking an exam, or get drunk while choosing a college. But a lot of people get drunk while choosing the most important life partner or a soulmate, or they get drunk when they get pregnant. They don't consult with experienced and successful elders when they make major life decisions. Being alcoholic is not a lifestyle, being alcoholic and then get pregnant and go for abortion or become a parent is not a lifestyle, being alcoholic and then join LGBTQ community is not a lifestyle, but there are a lot of people doing it. We learn to expect people, but we don't respect such decisions. Just like if you choose not to study and get an F in the exam, there is nothing to be respectful. Life is a big exam. Some people might have incompleted sexual development, go talk to experienced elders, and maybe you can find a better way to live. Science research shows a big portion of LGBTQ become homosexual simply because of the environment. Anyway, a lot of LGBTQ are alcoholic, over 80% HIV or sexual disease are transferred from gay people, There is always an option in life.


Two rights don't make it wrong and three wrongs don't make it right.

We must prayer for our school district. We must pray for the mental health of this nation.

Parents get your hearts to this Forum: Chino Valley school district’s first Parent Information Forum of the 2019-20 school year will include information about drug abuse trends, social media, technology issues and mental health resources at 6:30 p.m. Wednesday, Aug. 28 in the multipurpose room at Chino High, 5472 Park Place.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.